Effective Programs in Middle and High School Mathematics: A Best-Evidence Synthesis

Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Generalized Causal Inference

2001 • 12,893 citations

From dissertation abstracts international

1974 • 12,253 citations

Practical Meta-Analysis

2000 • 8,806 citations

National Council of Teachers of Mathematics

1979 • 8,727 citations

Cooperative Learning: Theory, Research and Practice

1983 • 3,831 citations

Intelligent Tutoring Goes To School in the Big City

1997 • 1,124 citations

Comprehensive School Reform and Achievement: A Meta-Analysis

2003 • 777 citations

Do studies of statistical power have an effect on the power of studies?

1989 • 743 citations

Best-Evidence Synthesis: An Alternative to Meta-Analytic and Traditional Reviews

1986 • 627 citations

International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement

1998 • 626 citations

Three conditions under which experiments and observational studies produce comparable causal estimates: New findings from within‐study comparisons

2008 • 585 citations

Perspectives on Evidence-Based Research in Education—What Works? Issues in Synthesizing Educational Program Evaluations

2008 • 522 citations

Enhancing Mathematical Reasoning in the Classroom: The Effects of Cooperative Learning and Metacognitive Training

2003 • 426 citations

Effective Programs in Elementary Mathematics: A Best-Evidence Synthesis

2008 • 378 citations

Highlights from the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS), 2003. NCES 2005-005.

2004 • 369 citations

Effectiveness of Reading and Mathematics Software Products: Findings from the First Student Cohort

2007 • 324 citations

Improve: A Multidimensional Method For Teaching Mathematics in Heterogeneous Classrooms

1997 • 305 citations

Effective Reading Programs for Middle and High Schools: A Best‐Evidence Synthesis

2008 • 280 citations

Untitled

2002 • 245 citations

Assessing the Impact of "Standards"-Based Middle Grades Mathematics Curriculum Materials on Student Achievement

2003 • 199 citations

The Effects of Peer-Assisted Learning Strategies and Curriculum-Based Measurement on the Mathematics Performance of Secondary Students with Disabilities

2003 • 187 citations

The Impact of Two Standards-Based Mathematics Curricula on Student Achievement in Massachusetts

2001 • 168 citations

Mastery learning in classroom instruction

1975 • 154 citations

Standards-based school mathematics curricula: What are they? What do students learn?

2003 • 151 citations

The effects of metacognitive training versus worked‐out examples on students' mathematical reasoning

2003 • 146 citations

Interactions among Instructional Practices, Curriculum, and Student Achievement: The Case of Standards-Based High School Mathematics

2001 • 142 citations

Classwide Curriculum-Based Measurement: Helping General Educators Meet the Challenge of Student Diversity

1994 • 142 citations

Cooperative Learning in the Secondary Mathematics Classroom

1997 • 136 citations

Studying Large-Scale Reforms of Instructional Practice: An Example from Mathematics and Science

2003 • 135 citations

What Doesn’t Work: The Challenge and Failure of the What Works Clearinghouse to Conduct Meaningful Reviews of Studies of Mathematics Curricula

2006 • 134 citations

Effects of Metacognitive Training Embedded in Cooperative Settings on Mathematical Problem Solving

1999 • 131 citations

Effects of Standards-Based Mathematics Education: A Study of the Core-Plus Mathematics Project Algebra and Functions Strand

2000 • 124 citations

Untitled

1998 • 122 citations

Making Progress Toward Graduation Evidence from the Talent Development High School Model

2005 • 120 citations

The Effects of Cooperative Learning on Student Achievement and Motivation in a High School Geometry Class

1996 • 118 citations

Effects of Multilevel Versus Unilevel Metacognitive Training on Mathematical Reasoning

2001 • 99 citations

Computer-Based Integrated Learning Systems in the Elementary and Middle Grades: A Critical Review and Synthesis of Evaluation Reports

1992 • 96 citations

Facing the Future: A Focus on Mathematical Literacy among Australian 15-Year-Old Students in PISA 2003.

2004 • 94 citations

Effect of Technology-Enhanced Continuous Progress Monitoring on Math Achievement

2007 • 90 citations

Mastery Learning and Student Teams: A Factorial Experiment in Urban General Mathematics Classes

1984 • 88 citations

Using Classwide Peer Tutoring to Teach Beginning Algebra Problem-Solving Skills in Heterogeneous Classrooms

1997 • 74 citations

On-line Tutoring for Math Achievement Testing: A Controlled Evaluation

2007 • 70 citations

No Magic Bullet: 3D Video Games in Education

2002 • 68 citations

Meeting the Curricular Needs of Academically Low-Achieving Students in Middle Grade Mathematics

2006 • 68 citations

Journal of Research in Reading

2004 • 60 citations

The Effects of Curriculum on Achievement in Second-Year Algebra: The Example of the University of Chicago School Mathematics Project

2001 • 59 citations

The Implementation and Impact of Evidence-Based Mathematics Reforms in High-Poverty Middle Schools: A Multi-Site, Multi-Year Study.

2006 • 57 citations

The quality of systematic reviews of effectiveness in literacy learning in English: a ‘tertiary’ review

2006 • 55 citations

Some experiments in diagnostic teaching

1993 • 55 citations

10. Synthesizing the Research

2016 • 55 citations

Nonexperimental Replications of Social Experiments: A Systematic Review

2014 • 54 citations

Comprehensive reform for urban high schools: a talent development approach

2003 • 53 citations

Games and Teams

1972 • 52 citations

An experimental study of the effects of Cognitive Tutor® Algebra I on student knowledge and attitude

2002 • 52 citations

Improving mathematics and science education: A longitudinal investigation of the relationship between reform-oriented instruction and student achievement

2006 • 50 citations

The Effects of Computer-Augmented Geometry Instruction on Student Performance and Attitudes

2002 • 50 citations

Using computer algebra systems in mathematical classrooms

2003 • 46 citations

Integrating Reform‐Oriented Math Instruction in Special Education Settings

2007 • 46 citations

The Impact of a Professional Development Program on Student Achievement in Grade 6 Mathematics

2006 • 45 citations

Comparing and Contrasting the National Research Council Report On Evaluating Curricular Effectiveness With the What Works Clearinghouse Approach

2006 • 45 citations

The Core-Plus Mathematics Project

2020 • 44 citations

REVIEW OF EVALUATION STUDIES OF MATHEMATICS AND SCIENCE CURRICULA AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT MODELS

2004 • 40 citations

An Evaluation of a Level-One Instructional Videodisc Program

1987 • 36 citations

Catching Up: Effect of theTalent Development Ninth-Grade Instructional Interventions in Reading and Mathematics in High-Poverty High Schools

2004 • 36 citations

"Standards"-based Mathematics Curricula and Secondary Students' Performance on Standardized Achievement Tests.

2007 • 35 citations

Mathematics Achievement in Cooperative versus Individualistic Goal-Structured High School Classrooms

1986 • 35 citations

Integrated Mathematics Interfaced With Science

1997 • 35 citations

Teaching Practices and Student Achievement: Report of First-Year Findings from the 'Mosaic' Study of Systemic Initiatives in Mathematics and Science

2000 • 34 citations

Miami-Dade County Public Schools

2000 • 34 citations

Student Attainment in the Connected Mathematics Curriculum

2020 • 33 citations

Are integrated learning systems effective learning support tools?

1996 • 32 citations

Upgrading the High School Math Curriculum: Math Course-Taking Patterns in Seven High Schools in California and New York

1996 • 31 citations

The use of a cognitive tutoring system in the improvement of the abstract reasoning component of word problem solving

1999 • 30 citations

The Effects of Cooperative Group Work Versus Independent Practice on the Learning of Some Problem‐Solving Strategies

1992 • 30 citations

Assessing the Impact of Computer Integration on Students

1998 • 29 citations

An Evaluation of the Connected Mathematics Project

2002 • 29 citations

Mindless or mindful use of integrated learning systems

1994 • 28 citations

The effect of geometry tool software on high school geometry achievement

1991 • 27 citations

Responding to Calls for Change in High School Mathematics: Implications for Collegiate Mathematics

2003 • 26 citations

Developing Mathematics Skills in Low-Achieving High School Students through Curriculum-Based Assessment

1989 • 26 citations

Curriculum-Based Measurements

1991 • 24 citations

The Effects of Cooperative Learning with Intergroup Competition on the Math Achievement of Seventh Grade Students.

1992 • 23 citations

Structured Cooperative Learning and Achievement in a High School Mathematics Class.

1993 • 22 citations

Achievement in Basic Math Skills for Low Performing Students

1988 • 21 citations

The Effects of Using Software Tools on Mathematical Problem Solving in Secondary Schools

1992 • 20 citations

Reading and genetics: an introduction

2006 • 20 citations

The Consequences of a Problem-Based Mathematics Curriculum

2004 • 20 citations

The Impact of Staff Development on Implementation and Student Achievement

1987 • 20 citations

A Comparison of Traditional and Reform Mathematics Curricula in an Eighth-Grade Classroom

2003 • 19 citations

Effects of Computer Algebra System (CAS) with Metacognitive Training on Mathematical Reasoning

2003 • 19 citations

Computer-Assisted Problem Solving in School Mathematics

1972 • 18 citations

The BIG Accommodation Model: The Direct Instruction Model for Secondary Schools

2002 • 18 citations

Learning games and student teams: Their effects on student attitudes and achievement.

1972 • 17 citations

Demonstration of the Use of Computer-Assisted Instruction with Handicapped Children. Final Report.

1978 • 16 citations

Comparative Effectiveness of Carnegie Learning's "Cognitive Tutor Bridge to Algebra" Curriculum: A Report of a Randomized Experiment in the Maui School District. Research Report.

2007 • 15 citations

Incremental Development: A Breakthrough in Mathematics.

1982 • 14 citations

Efficacy of educational technology in elementary and secondary classrooms: a meta-analysis of the research literature from 1992--2002

2002 • 14 citations

The Effects of a Generalizable Mathematics Skills Instructional Intervention on the Mathematics Achievement of Learners in Secondary CTE Programs

2003 • 14 citations

Using Accelerated Math To Enhance Student Achievement in High School Mathematics Courses.

2001 • 14 citations

An experimental study on the effectiveness of metacognitive and heuristic problem solving techniques on computational performance of students in mathematics

1998 • 14 citations

Removed from the List: A Comparative Longitudinal Case Study of a Reconstitution-Eligible School.

2002 • 13 citations

Evaluating the Impact of Cai on Mathematics Learning: Computer Immersion Project

1986 • 13 citations

Students' Perceptions and Attitudes in a Standards-Based High School Mathematics Curriculum.

1998 • 13 citations

The Effects of Teaching Euclidean Geometry via Transformations on Student Achievement and Attitudes in Tenth-Grade Geometry

1972 • 13 citations

The Effect of School Renaissance on Student Achievement in Two Mississippi School Districts.

2005 • 12 citations

An Evaluation of the Mastering Fractions Level-One Instructional Videodisc Program.

1986 • 12 citations

THE EFFECT OF THE CARNEGIE ALGEBRA TUTOR ON STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT AND ATTITUDE IN INTRODUCTORY HIGH SCHOOL ALGEBRA

2001 • 12 citations

Policy Implications of Cooperative Learning on the Achievement and Attitudes of Secondary School Mathematics Students

2000 • 12 citations

The Impact of Reform Instruction on Student Mathematics Achievement: An Example of a Summative Evaluation of a Standards-Based Curriculum

2008 • 12 citations

A Longitudinal Study of Students Completing Four Years of UCSMP Mathematics

1993 • 11 citations

Math Corps Summer Camp: An Inner City Intervention Program

2001 • 11 citations

The appalachia model mathematics program for gifted students

1995 • 11 citations

AN EMERGING PROFILE OF THE MATHEMATICAL ACHIEVEMENT OF STUDENTS IN THE CORE-PLUS MATHEMATICS PROJECT

1998 • 11 citations

The Effects of Teaching Euclidean Geometry via Transformations on Student Achievement and Attitudes in Tenth-Grade Geometry

1972 • 11 citations

The Effects of the Cognitive Tutor Algebra on Student Attitudes and Achievement In a 9th Grade Algebra Course

2004 • 11 citations

STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT IN SMALL-GROUP INSTRUCTION VERSUS TEACHER-CENTERED INSTRUCTION IN MATHEMATICS

1992 • 10 citations

An Evaluation of Saxon’s Algebra Text

1987 • 10 citations

A Commonwealth Consortium to Develop, Implement and Evaluate a Pilot Program of Computer-Assisted Instruction for Urban High Schools. Final Report.

1971 • 10 citations

The Effects of School Renaissance on Student Achievement in Two Mississippi School Districts: A Longitudinal Quasi-Experimental Study.

2005 • 9 citations

Development of Proportional Reasoning in a Problem-Based Middle School Curriculum.

1997 • 9 citations

On Evaluating Curricular Effectiveness

2004 • 9 citations

Intrinsic Orientation Profiles and Learning Mathematics in CAI Settings

1988 • 8 citations

Effects of Using a Problem Solving Approach to Algebra I Instruction.

1993 • 8 citations

The effects of computer-assisted instruction on middle school mathematics achievement

2005 • 8 citations

Brief research report

2001 • 8 citations

Using the concrete-representational-abstract teaching sequence to increase algebra problem-solving skills

2003 • 7 citations

Students’ Conceptions of Mathematics and the Transition from a Standards-Based Reform Curriculum to College Mathematics

1999 • 7 citations

Skill performance comparability of two algebra programs on an eighth-grade population

1992 • 6 citations

The effect of computer-assisted instruction in improving mathematics performance of low-achieving ninth-grade students

1991 • 6 citations

The association between the use of accelerated math and students' math achievement

2005 • 5 citations

Identifying and Preparing Disadvantaged and Minority Youth for High-Level Academic Achievement

1993 • 5 citations

An Examination of the Performance Gains of Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Students on a Mathematics Performance Assessment within the QUASAR Project.

1995 • 5 citations

Teaching students with learning disabilities to solve word-problems : a comparison of a cognitive strategy and a traditional textbook method

1996 • 5 citations

Towards Individualized Instruction with Technology-Enabled Tools and Methods

2007 • 5 citations

The Effects of Computer Assisted Instruction in Basic Skills Courses on High-Risk Ninth Grade Students

1987 • 5 citations

An Experiment on Effects of Redundant Audio in Computer Based Instruction on Achievement, Attitude, and Learning Time in 10th Grade Math

1995 • 5 citations

Achievement and affective domains of Algebra I students in traditional or self-paced computer programs

1999 • 4 citations

Austin Collaborative for Mathematics Education 1999-2000 Evaluation.

2001 • 4 citations

Effects of Cooperative and Individual Integrated Learning System on Attitudes and Achievement in Mathematics

2005 • 4 citations

Selected effects of a computer game on achievement, attitude, and graphing ability in secondary school algebra

1985 • 4 citations

Improving High School Students' Mathematics Achievement through the Use of Motivational Strategies.

2001 • 4 citations

Differential Effectiveness of Three Kinds of Computer-Assisted Instruction.

1986 • 4 citations

Effects of a generative instructional design strategy on learning mathematics and on attitudes towards achievement

1997 • 4 citations

Creating opportunities for learning with mathematical tasks

2007 • 4 citations

Examining the effects of three methods of study skill group intervention with middle school underachievers

1982 • 3 citations

The Boeing Company Applied Academics Project Evaluation: Year Four. Evaluation Report.

1995 • 3 citations

The impact of the utilization of Advantage Learning Systems' technology on students' academic achievement

2002 • 3 citations

A Study To Determine the Effects of a Non-Traditional Approach to Algebra Instruction on Student Achievement.

1998 • 3 citations

Effects of goal setting procedures on students' mathematical achievement and self-efficacy

1999 • 3 citations

Secondary school mathematics in transition: A comparative study of mathematics curricula and student results

2001 • 3 citations

Improvement of Basic Mathematical Skills with PLATO: An Experiment

1983 • 3 citations

The impact of computer-enhanced learning environments on student achievement in remedial algebra: a comparison of teaching models

2005 • 2 citations

The Effect of a Hand-Held Calculator Curriculum in Selected Fundamentals of Mathematics Classes.

1978 • 2 citations

An intervention study in mathematical problem solving among selected junior high school students

1985 • 2 citations

The Evaluation of an Application-Oriented First-Year Algebra Program

1980 • 2 citations

A study of the effects of computer-assisted instruction and teacher instruction on achievement in mathematics

1997 • 2 citations

The impact of the Saxon Mathematics program on group achievement test scores

1994 • 2 citations

A comparative analysis of the plato computer-assisted instructional delivery system and the traditional individualized instructional program in two juvenile correctional facilities owned by the commonwealth of pennsylvania

1985 • 2 citations

Analysis of the Effects of a Mathematics/Social Work Intervention in the Middle School

1995 • 2 citations

The Evaluation of an Application-Oriented First-Year Algebra Program

1980 • 2 citations

Effect of computer application on generalization skills and achievement in a second year algebra course

1971 • 2 citations

Small-group cooperative learning and field-dependence/independence effects on achievement and affective behaviors in mathematics of secondary school students in Medan, Indonesia

1995 • 2 citations

The effects of Saxon's incremental review on computational skills and problem solving achievement of sixth grade students

1995 • 2 citations

Using heuristics to teach problem-solving in Algebra I: A metacognitively controlled approach

1991 • 1 citations

Middle-level summer school effectiveness as measured by student gains in achievement and attitude

2000 • 1 citations

Teaching Practices and Student Achievement: Evaluating Classroom-Based Education Reforms

2001 • 1 citations

An Investigation into the Effectiveness of Transition Mathematics.

1996 • 1 citations

The effect of mastery learning and wait time on student achievement and attitude in seventh and eighth grade mathematics

1988 • 1 citations

Effects of an incremental continuous review homework format on seventh-grade mathematics achievement

1990 • 1 citations

Constraints and Limitations in Evaluating Math Curricular Reform Efforts: Pacesetter Math Case Study.

1998 • 1 citations

Mashpee High School, Mashpee, MA. PLATO[R] Evaluation Series.

2002 • 1 citations

Effects of supplementary computer-assisted instruction on basic algebra 1 and basic algebra 2 achievement levels of mathematics at-risk minority students

1991 • 1 citations

A comparison of the effectiveness between the cooperative and individual learning on students' achievement and attitudes on a computer-assisted mathematics problem-solving task

1991 • 1 citations

A Pilot Program of High School Computer-Assisted Instruction Mathematics Courses

1974 • 1 citations

Multi-Year Large-Scale Field Studies of the Fundamental Skills Training Project's Intelligent Tutoring Systems.

2000 • 1 citations

An evaluation of the relationship of participation in a computer-based math program with student achievement

2003 • 1 citations

A Study of the Effects of Individualized Programmed Mathematics Experiments on Achievement and Attitudes of Seventh Grade Students.

1979 • 1 citations

A constructivist approach to computer-assisted mathematics instruction

1989 • 1 citations

Deleted Work

1955 • 0 citations